Talk:Kirby - Revision history

Alex95: /* Why does this page exist? */

2018-11-28T17:49:19Z

Why does this page exist?

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:49, 28 November 2018
Line 3:		Line 3:
	I like Kirby as much as the next guy, but the line "However, Kirby has never appeared with Starfy in any game except Super Smash Bros. Brawl." raises questions. Other characters like [[Link]] and [[Marth]] don't have a page, though [[Mario]] does due to his crossovers. Unless there are non-''Smash'' games with both Kirby and Starfy that haven't been added and this page is out of date, why does this page exist? [[User:Alex95\|Alex95]] ([[User talk:Alex95\|talk]]) 05:43, 28 November 2018 (UTC)		I like Kirby as much as the next guy, but the line "However, Kirby has never appeared with Starfy in any game except Super Smash Bros. Brawl." raises questions. Other characters like [[Link]] and [[Marth]] don't have a page, though [[Mario]] does due to his crossovers. Unless there are non-''Smash'' games with both Kirby and Starfy that haven't been added and this page is out of date, why does this page exist? [[User:Alex95\|Alex95]] ([[User talk:Alex95\|talk]]) 05:43, 28 November 2018 (UTC)
	:That's true. It looks like a regular user created the page [http://starfy.wikia.com/wiki/Kirby?action=history in 2009], and the staff kept it but I don't know if we ever established any notability criteria other than the pages being relevant to Starfy in some way. When a lot of people think of Starfy, they also think of Kirby (due to the similarities in style, even though the gameplay is significantly different and the developers are different), but officially they are unrelated. The trivia points on the article (in particular the Hitoshi Yamagami comment) also link them together. He's culturally relevant to Starfy. However, still maybe Kirby shouldn't have his own page but deserves a mention on [[The Legendary Starfy series fandom]] (a wanted page) if it is eventually created. --[[User:Torchickens\|Torchickens]] ([[User talk:Torchickens\|talk]]) 17:20, 28 November 2018 (UTC)		:That's true. It looks like a regular user created the page [http://starfy.wikia.com/wiki/Kirby?action=history in 2009], and the staff kept it but I don't know if we ever established any notability criteria other than the pages being relevant to Starfy in some way. When a lot of people think of Starfy, they also think of Kirby (due to the similarities in style, even though the gameplay is significantly different and the developers are different), but officially they are unrelated. The trivia points on the article (in particular the Hitoshi Yamagami comment) also link them together. He's culturally relevant to Starfy. However, still maybe Kirby shouldn't have his own page but deserves a mention on [[The Legendary Starfy series fandom]] (a wanted page) if it is eventually created. --[[User:Torchickens\|Torchickens]] ([[User talk:Torchickens\|talk]]) 17:20, 28 November 2018 (UTC)
			::The trivia interview is probably the only thing worth keeping, and can likely go on [[Starfy]]'s page trivia as well (maybe I'll pass it on to WiKirby, too). [[User:Alex95\|Alex95]] ([[User talk:Alex95\|talk]]) 17:49, 28 November 2018 (UTC)

Torchickens: Reply

2018-11-28T17:20:48Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:20, 28 November 2018
Line 2:		Line 2:

	I like Kirby as much as the next guy, but the line "However, Kirby has never appeared with Starfy in any game except Super Smash Bros. Brawl." raises questions. Other characters like [[Link]] and [[Marth]] don't have a page, though [[Mario]] does due to his crossovers. Unless there are non-''Smash'' games with both Kirby and Starfy that haven't been added and this page is out of date, why does this page exist? [[User:Alex95\|Alex95]] ([[User talk:Alex95\|talk]]) 05:43, 28 November 2018 (UTC)		I like Kirby as much as the next guy, but the line "However, Kirby has never appeared with Starfy in any game except Super Smash Bros. Brawl." raises questions. Other characters like [[Link]] and [[Marth]] don't have a page, though [[Mario]] does due to his crossovers. Unless there are non-''Smash'' games with both Kirby and Starfy that haven't been added and this page is out of date, why does this page exist? [[User:Alex95\|Alex95]] ([[User talk:Alex95\|talk]]) 05:43, 28 November 2018 (UTC)
			:That's true. It looks like a regular user created the page [http://starfy.wikia.com/wiki/Kirby?action=history in 2009], and the staff kept it but I don't know if we ever established any notability criteria other than the pages being relevant to Starfy in some way. When a lot of people think of Starfy, they also think of Kirby (due to the similarities in style, even though the gameplay is significantly different and the developers are different), but officially they are unrelated. The trivia points on the article (in particular the Hitoshi Yamagami comment) also link them together. He's culturally relevant to Starfy. However, still maybe Kirby shouldn't have his own page but deserves a mention on [[The Legendary Starfy series fandom]] (a wanted page) if it is eventually created. --[[User:Torchickens\|Torchickens]] ([[User talk:Torchickens\|talk]]) 17:20, 28 November 2018 (UTC)

Alex95: /* Why does this page exist? */ new section

2018-11-28T05:43:40Z

Why does this page exist?: new section

New page

== Why does this page exist? ==

I like Kirby as much as the next guy, but the line "However, Kirby has never appeared with Starfy in any game except Super Smash Bros. Brawl." raises questions. Other characters like [[Link]] and [[Marth]] don't have a page, though [[Mario]] does due to his crossovers. Unless there are non-''Smash'' games with both Kirby and Starfy that haven't been added and this page is out of date, why does this page exist? [[User:Alex95|Alex95]] ([[User talk:Alex95|talk]]) 05:43, 28 November 2018 (UTC)